It’s probably every woman’s dream to get through the day without a smear in their eyeliner. If you’ve been wearing eyeliner for a long time, you might be thinking the same. But if you’re using a waterproof eyeliner, you’ll have better chances to flaunt your beautiful eye makeup even when you’re working all day or partying all night! But how can you choose the best waterproof eyeliner?
With the overwhelming options for the best waterproof eyeliners on the market, you’ve probably been shifting brands to find the ultimate eyeliner for the perfect all-day winged eyes. But fret not! Our in-depth reviews and buying guide will help you out!
List of the Top 10 Best Waterproof Eyeliners in 2023
Last update on 2023-03-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
10. Tarte Sex Kitten Eyeliner -Black -Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
Looking for a good eyeliner could be challenging for women who have sensitive skin. Good thing you can trust this eyeliner by Tarte as it works well with people who have sensitive skin. This gel eyeliner will also look perfect on the edges of your upper or lower eyelid.
It is made out of naturally made waxes, making it very creamy, and its tip will surely glide smoothly on the eye area. You won’t have to struggle with pulling, smearing, and skipping with this waterproof eyeliner. It is very easy to apply and it definitely lasts for many hours. This eyeliner would be a great addition to your favorite daily eye makeup tool.
- Suitable for women with sensitive skin
- Made out of naturally made waxes
- Glides smoothly on the eye area
- Smudge proof
- Lasts for many hours
9. PTKOONN Liquid Eyeliner
With the help of this perfect black liquid eyeliner by PTKOONN, it is now possible to achieve that fashionable cat eye. This waterproof eyeliner can stay for many hours, and it can help you pull off your desired eye shape.
It can also help you to effortlessly create an amazing wing. Though it is a liquid eyeliner, it can be glided smoothly and easily on your eye area. It also does not easily smear even when you wear it for hours. This Liquid eyeliner is very easy to apply and can be used by beginners. It dries very quickly but if you’re all done for the day, you can easily remove it with water.
- Lasts for many hours
- Not skipping and smearing
- Can be used by beginners
- Dries very quickly
8. stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
If you’re a beginner, you might try using this waterproof liquid eyeliner made by stila. The highlight of this eyeliner is the very fine tip that guides your hand to create precise and smooth lines. This eyeliner is very easy to apply and it really stays on where you put it. You won’t have a hard time applying it because it glides effortlessly and you will not experience any smudging or running.
Even if you are trying out an eyeliner for the first time, you can pull off that defined thin line with the help of this liquid eyeliner. You can be confident on wearing this eyeliner as it is very long-lasting and it is reliable for a whole workday. Furthermore, it dries quickly.
- Perfect for beginners
- Easy to apply
- Does not smudge and run
- Very long-lasting
- Dries quickly
7. MIA ADORA Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener
This waterproof eyeliner pencil can be your reliable eye makeup tool as it glides on very smoothly on the eye area. It does not easily smudge or budge and it definitely stays on without fading or running. Even when you’re rubbing or touching your eyes, this eyeliner will not fade and smear.
You can also trust the eyeliner if you want to emphasize your water lines and add some additional appeal and definition to your eyes. With this eyeliner by MIA ADORA, you can easily pull off those smoky eyes, and enhance your eyes with beautiful strokes and lines. Its tip can easily and accurately create thin or thick lines that can surely improve your eye shape and look. Sweating won’t be a problem as this eyeliner is waterproof.
- Does not smudge and budge
- Emphasizes waterlines
- Adds additional definition to eyes
- Improves eye shape
6. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil
It is not always required to retrace your steps on using traditional pencil eyeliner that needs a sharpener; you can always add this retractable eyeliner by NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP into your eye makeup procedure. Achieving that fashionable and defined eye will now be very easy and simple; just simply twist this eyeliner and you can start drawing your stylish winged-out eye makeup.
Since it is made out of creamy formula, this eyeliner is sure to last for many hours. It does not quickly fade as it is smudge-proof, and also, it glides very smoothly on the eye area. While it offers very promising results, NYX also makes sure they don’t harm animals when manufacturing cosmetic products; this eyeliner pencil is cruelty-free.
- Retractable eyeliner
- Makes winged-out eye makeup easy to achieve
- Creamy formula
- Long-lasting and smudge-proof
- Glides smoothly
5. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner
If you want a bold and defined eyeliner, then you might consider using this gel eyeliner by Maybelline New York as it is made out of highly concentrated pigments. This gel eyeliner will definitely enhance your makeup, giving it an intense and sophisticated look and a long-lasting effect that usually stays on for 24 hours.
It is surely safe to be applied on your eye area as it is ophthalmologist, dermatologist, and allergy tested. This waterproof gel eyeliner is available in 10 different shades, and they are recommended for those who have sensitive skin and for those who wear contact lenses.
- Made out of highly concentrated pigments
- Enhances eye makeup
- Stays on for 24 hours
- Ophthalmologist, dermatologist, and allergy tested
- Available in 10 different shades
- Suitable for sensitive skin
4. Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer
This eye defining pencil made by Rimmel might be a good option if you are talking about high precision and excellent lasting power. With this eye definer, you can be able to pull off those stylish and smoldering eyes. It has a very soft texture, a fine tip, and it is definitely reliable for an all-day makeup look.
By using this eye definer, you no longer need to use a separate sharpener as it is a self-sharpening feature. It is a versatile eye definer because it can look absolutely fashionable with any type of eyeshadow, mascara or highlighter. It is available in 4 different colors and they are all non-toxic and safe to use.
- Excellent lasting power
- High precision
- Self-sharpening feature
- Versatile eye definer
3. L’Oréal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner
If you are one of those women who want to have a glossy finish makeup, you might probably love this eyeliner by L’Oreal Paris. With this infallible lacquer eyeliner, you can easily achieve that chic and glossy eye. It is very easy to use as it glides very smoothly and gently around your eye area.
It also leaves a precise line or design and a very shiny finish that amazingly stays on for 24 hours. This gel eyeliner is available in different colors and they are all very easy to apply. You do not have to worry about using this eyeliner when you are sweating because it is water resistant and it does not smear easily.
- Glossy finish
- Glides smoothly
- Stays on for 24 hours
- Easy to apply
- Water resistant
2. LA PURE Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp
With this waterproof eyeliner stamp by LA PURE, you do not have to manually draw wings around your eyes anymore. By just stamping this eyeliner on your wings, you can instantly create a perfectly done cat eye. You don’t need to worry about having your wings getting smeared, faded or erased because this waterproof eyeliner stamp is smudge-proof and waterproof.
You can be certain that every application of this eyeliner stamp will give you a long-lasting effect that will stay on for hours. Every eyeliner stamp is specially made to look perfectly well with each eye, leaving a consistent and balanced shape every application. Furthermore, this eyeliner has double-sided pens, which makes it very handy and very practical to use.
- No need to manually draw wings
- Stays on for hours
- Leaves a consistent and balanced shape on both eyes
1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner
This stellar ink liner made by NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP can definitely help you achieve that stunning and long-lasting cat eye effect. It also features a very fine tip for precise application, letting you draw very thin to thick lines. This ink liner is very easy to apply and it will definitely last all day.
Even after many hours, your eyeliner will not fade and it will still be intact and undamaged for it is certainly waterproof. You can freely go as thin or thick with this ink liner. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP’s products, including this ink liner, is approved and recognized by PETA as a cruelty-free brand, so you can be sure that all of their products are not tested on animals.
- Helps you achieve a long-lasting cat eye effect
- Very fine tip for precise application
- Easy to apply
- Lasts all day
How to Choose the Best Waterproof Eyeliner
Obviously, the highlight of waterproof eyeliners is their waterproofing properties. It means that the eyeliner does not easily smudge, wear off, or transfer on the lids. It should last long and surprisingly, some waterproof eyeliner brands can even last up to 24 hours.
If you can test it out, you can swatch some on your hand and observe how long it can last under sweaty, oily, and wet conditions. You can even test it on running water. If this is not possible, you may read or watch some reviews on how long the eyeliner can last or if it easily wears off or not.
- TIP MATERIAL:
Apart from the best formula, the tip material can make or break your eyeliner. Whether it uses an applicator or a pencil type, it is better to opt for eyeliners that are designed with a fine tip as this can render smooth and precise application.
You can also indulge in a seamless and easy application, allowing you to draw those strokes and lines right on the dot. If you’re trying an eyeliner for the first time, you can go for a brush or felt tip so you can start with easy and quick strokes and lines.
One of the most important factors to consider is the formula or the ingredients used on the product. Since our eyes are delicate parts of the body, they need gentle care and treatment. That’s why it is vital to check the labels for the ingredients whether they consist of harsh chemicals or other ingredients that may cause irritations or can trigger allergies. This is definitely a must when you have sensitive skin or your allergic to certain types of ingredients.
When checking the ingredients, go for waterproof eyeliners that are free from parabens, mineral oils, preservatives, and synthetic or artificial fragrances. You should also skip those eyeliners that contain alcohol, menthol, or alcohol denatured. If it also contains DEA, MEA, TEA, Phthalates, and lead, don’t buy that eyeliner. These are harmful chemicals that may cause adverse effects and much worse, may damage your eyes.
- TYPE OF EYELINER:
Waterproof eyeliners come in different forms. Probably the most common types that you see on the market today are liquid eyeliners, pencil eyeliners, gel eyeliners, and matte eyeliners. They may come in different forms but the formula makes a huge difference in terms of the quality and easy application.
If you’re a beginner and you want to have more control when creating winged eyes or quick and easy lines on your eyes, you can choose pencil eyeliners. Gel liners with a very fine tip applicator would also be a good option. On the other hand, liquid eyeliners require a steady hand and beginners might need to get a hang of it before creating the perfect winged eyes and smooth strokes. If you want to avoid ugly smudged lines on your lids, skip very waxy eyeliners.
If you’re looking for the best waterproof eyeliner to add in your huge stash of eye makeup, you should go for an eyeliner that can keep up with you for the whole day. While you focus on the waterproofing properties, you should never brush off the ingredients and always make sure it’s safe to use, especially when you have sensitive skin. Consider the formula, the tip material, and how long it can last.
With the plethora of makeup brands to choose from, there’s always a dilemma in finding the perfect eyeliner. But we’ve narrowed down your options with our top 10 list and comprehensive buying guide. Hope this helps!